The Washington Post

January 21, 1996, Sunday, Final Edition


LENGTH: 1637 words

HEADLINE: THE GERMAN INVASION; British One Got Better Press, But the
Teutonic Influence Endures

BYLINE: Mark Jenkins, Special to The Washington Post


     The Beatles are back on the charts again, but to the international
pop music market it's almost as if they never went away: The Anglo-
American alliance that began its dominance with "I Want to Hold Your
Hand" is as secure as ever.  Countries as diverse as India, Japan and
Argentina have developed their own pop stars, but few have proved
exportable.  Globally, the history of popular music during the last 25
years is an account of just three nations: the United States, the United
Kingdom and, well, Germany.

     If judged strictly on Billboard chart position, of course, the
latter wouldn't make the list.  The occasional Teutonic commercial
success -- Nena's chirpy 1984 hit, "99 Luftballons," say -- is just the
sort of forgettable fluke that proves that Germany (like such occasional
hit-makers as Sweden or Brazil) is not a serious contender. Indeed, of
the '70s-vintage German bands that are (once again) being discovered,
only Kraftwerk ever entered the American Top 40: An edited version of
the 22-minute "Autobahn" made it all the way to No. 25 in
1975. Yet Capitol, the same label that's put the Beatles' leftovers in
play, has also recently reissued such Kraftwerk albums as "Trans-Europe
Express" and "The Man Machine."

     Even less known in the United States is Can, perhaps the best of
the spacey, early '70s German ensembles that combined elements from
avant-garde composer Karlheinz Stockhausen and the Velvet Underground
with jazz, funk, dub and other influences.  This style is often called
"Krautrock," after a song from 1973's "Faust IV," the final album by
Faust, another German group of the period.

     Though discs by Faust and such other contemporaries as Neu are hard
to find, Can's catalogue is again available through an alliance between
Spoon, a French label, and Mute, an English one with American
distribution.  Spoon/Mute began reissuing the Cologne jam band's albums
in 1989, although they didn't become widely available in the United
States until recently. Its latest projects are "Can: Anthology 25
Years," a two-CD set, and "Cannibalism 3," the third sampler of solo
work by the former band members.

     Though Can recorded for a decade, its best albums -- "Ege Bamyasi,"
"Future Days" and "Soon Over Babaluma" -- were made between 1972 and
1974. Kraftwerk hit its stride soon after, with "Autobahn" (1974),
"Radio Activity" (1975), "Trans-Europe Express" (1977) and "The Man
Machine" (1978).  This period also produced Berlin's Tangerine Dream,
whose burblings presaged much of contemporary "ambient" music -- "They
sound like silt seeping on the ocean floor," wrote Lester Bangs, not
altogether unadmiringly, in 1977 - and synth-based movie soundtracks.
(The group has composed a number of the latter itself.)  Around the same
time, Munich became a disco powerhouse with the success of Silver
Convention ("Fly, Robin, Fly") and especially Giorgio Moroder, who
produced a dozen Top 40 (and dance-floor) hits for American singer Donna

     Because Moroder's music was once ubiquitous and soon faded, his
reputation is in decline.  His artier contemporaries, however, have
never been more prized.  "Kraftwerk invented the pristine, precise,
surface-oriented pop phuture we now inhabit," argues British rock critic
Simon Reynolds, one of the most vehement advocates of the position that
rock-and-roll is old-fashioned and space-rock is cutting-edge.  (However
valid this argument may be aesthetically, it's not exactly historical:
Leon Theremin's pioneering synthesizer is a contemporary of the electric

     Proponents of Kraftwerk and its Teutonic peers have long claimed
that theirs is the music of the future (or "phuture").  The suit-and-tie
scientist look cultivated by Kraftwerk founders Ralf Hutter and Florian
Schneider emphasizes their distance from messy, human rock-and-roll, and
even the Dusseldorf band's advocates find it difficult to write about
them without mentioning such German inventions as the V2 rocket and
methamphetamine.  "In the music of Kraftwerk, and bands like them
present and to come," exulted Bangs in 1975, "the machines not merely
overpower and play the human beings but absorb them, until the scientist
and his technology, having developed a higher consciousness of its own,
are one and the same."

     It may not have furthered a higher consciousness, but by the late
'70s Krautrock had become a significant resource for experimental
rockers (mostly British) dissatisfied with the relatively modest damage
done by punk to traditional rock.  The first big-time Brits to make the
pilgrimage to Berlin were David Bowie and Brian Eno, who made two
Kraftwerk-smitten albums, "Low" and "Heroes," there in 1977.  Public
Image Ltd., the group founded by John Lydon after he abandoned the Sex
Pistols and his Johnny Rotten moniker, drew heavily from Can, especially
for its "Second Edition" album.  (After departing Public Image, bassist
Jah Wobble made two EPs with Can's Holger Czukay, one enlisting U2
guitarist the Edge, the other Can drummer Jaki Liebezeit.)  "I Am Damo
Suzuki," proclaimed a song on British post-punk band the Fall's 1985
album, "This Nation's Saving Grace," in honor of Can's Japanese sometime
singer, Kenjo "Damo" Suzuki.

     Krautrock also influenced such British post-punk synth bands as
Cabaret Voltaire, Prag Vec, Throbbing Gristle and (early) Human League.
Within a few years, a new generation of bands had crafted a commercial
version of these groups' synth-based sound.  Depeche Mode, while
retaining some of its English pop sensibility, recorded in Berlin and
cultivated a Weimar graphic style; so did Nitzer Ebb, which actually
tried to pass as German by designating its music "Nitzerebbprodukt."
(The Chelmsford return address gave the band away, though.)

     As Kraftwerk's albums became less frequent, its influence grew.
Perhaps the crucial event was hip-hop innovator Afrika Bambaataa's 1982
single, "Planet Rock," which borrowed its "perfect beat" from "Trans-
Europe Express."  This Bronx/Dusseldorf synthesis was "the start of hip-
hop," insists British pop-music historian Jon Savage, and it's true that
early hip-hop and break-dancing was frequently based on mechanical beats
derived, directly or indirectly, from Kraftwerk.  Though heavy metal,
jazz and many other influences were eventually incorporated, hip-hop's
early pulse was often the robotic beat of the man-machines.  (Locally,
Trouble Funk's "Trouble Funk Express" adapted the techno-pulse of
"Trans-Europe Express" to go-go's looser swing.)  [I remember seeing an
early 1980's issue of England's music tabloid NME (NEW MUSICAL EXPRESS)
which placed at the top of its Top Ten Hip-Hop list Moroder's 15 minute-
plus masterpiece, "Evolution," which was recorded and released in 1978,
at his peak.  This is indeed Moroder's best-ever achievement, as far as
*I'm* concerned, and I've been a Moroder fan since 1977, ever since he
produced Donna Summer's "I Feel Love" and Munich Machine's "Get on the
Funk Train" (*another* 15 minute-plus bonanza).  It's really a pity that
critics continue to rant about Kraftwerk, Faust, Can, and Neu to the
detriment of Tangerine Dream, Klaus Shulze and Giorgio Moroder.  Moroder
is much more responsible for Eurodisco and Hi Energy than Kraftwerk ever
was.  It is Moroder who is the father of the Pet Shop Boys and Erasure,
not Kraftwerk.  -- Steven Feldman]

     Reportedly overwhelmed by bringing their technique and sound into
the digital age, Kraftwerk hasn't released an album of new material
since 1986's "Electric Cafe."  The band's most recent release, 1991's
"The Mix," remodeled such tracks as "Computer Love" to acknowledge the
harsher, harder beats of such Germanic '80s and '90s successors as
Einsturzende Neubauten, Deutsche Amerikanische Freundschaft and Die
Krupps.  (Recently, Tangerine Dream also issued an album of its
standards remixed for the more aggressive demands of today's dance

     If Kraftwerk's influence has become as universal (albeit less
acknowledged) as that of the Beatles, groups like Can are again the
darlings of the underground.  Virtually all the acts on London's trendy
Too Pure label -- Stereolab, Th' Faith Healers, Laika, Moonshake, Pram,
Long Fin Killie, Mouse on Mars -- are indebted to Can.  (Most of the Too
Pure bands are British, although Mouse on Mars has a Cologne return
address and Stereolab's French singer, Laetitia Sadier, gives the band a
continental aspect.)  Such post-punk veterans as Sonic Youth and Julian
Cope, who wore a Neu T-shirt when he performed at the Black Cat in
November, have taken up the cause as well.

     Although Can's music is sometimes cosmic in a '70s mode that has
failed to return to fashion, it augurs many of the most celebrated '90s
bands that favor groove and atmosphere over melody and lyrics.  This is
the music that Simon Reynolds, while conceding its 25-year-old
inspiration, has unconvincingly dubbed "post-rock."  "Basically, when it
comes to psychedelic dance music," opines Reynolds of Can, "those crafty
Krauts wrote the book."

     Those advocating post-rock's inevitable triumph tend not to be
thrilled with the pop music that's actually selling these days: grunge,
Brit-pop, Hootie and the Blowfish.  Indeed, one of things that commends
Kraftwerk, Can and their followers to rock sophisticates -- their
emotionlessness -- may be just what undermines them in the Anglo-
American market.

     "We are showroom dummies," sang Kraftwerk robotically, and later
devised a live performance in which the band members were impersonated
by automatons.  On many of its best-known songs -- "Autobahn," "Trans-
Europe Express," "Tour De France" -- Kraftwerk tried to embody not human
exhilaration but the sensation of speed itself.  Hutter, Schneider and
company aspired to be "man-machines," creatures that wouldn't want to
hold your hand -- and indeed might not even have any hands.

     Can's chilliness was less programmatic, but this band too eschewed
popular music's customary emotional concerns.  Frequently chanted and
submerged in the mix, its multi-lingual vocals were simply another sonic
element, texture rather than thought.  Whatever connection Can makes
with the listener is a matter of sound, not sense.

     Perhaps that's why Krautrock remains a storehouse to be plundered
by pop's cognoscenti rather than -- as Depeche Mode's knockoff once
proclaimed itself -- "Music for the Masses."  Rock's history can't be
written without Germany, but more people are interested in scraps of
music from the Beatles' Hamburg days than with the world-altering sounds
Kraftwerk and Can fashioned nearby.  Krautrock's influence is vast, but
few CD buyers are ready for the day when the machines play the human

GRAPHIC: Photo, photofest, Germany's Fab Four: Kraftwerk's Ralf Hutter,
Florian Schneider, Karl Bartos and Wolfgang Flur.